- Mariano Rivera (NYY) 9
- Brian Wilson (SF) 9
- Joakim Soria (KC) 8.5
- Heath Bell (SD) 8.25
- Joe Nathan (Min) 8
- Andrew Bailey (Oak) 8
- Neftali Feliz (Tex) 8
- Aroldis Chapman (Cin) 7.75
- Jonathan Papelbon (Bos) 7.5
- Carlos Marmol (CHC) 7.5
- Jose Valverde (Hou) 7.5
- Brad Lidge (Phi) 7.25
- Jonathan Broxton (LAD) 7.25
- Chris Sale (CHW) 7.25
- Francisco Rodriguez (NYM) 7.25
- Huston Street (Col) 7.25
- Leo Nunez (Fla) 7.25
- John Axford (Mil) 7.25
- J.J. Putz (Ari) 7.25
- Ryan Franklin (Stl) 7.25
- Brandon Lyon (Hou) 7
- David Aardsma (Sea) 7
- Chris Perez (Cle) 7
- J.P Howell (TB) 7
- Frank Francisco (Tor) 7
- Evan Meek (Pit) 7
- Kevin Gregg (Bal) 7
- Fernando Rodney (LAA) 7
- Craig Kimbrel (Atl) 7
- Drew Storen (Was) 7
